It’s your funeral, an investigation of death care in the Funeral Industry in Australia Comment

By: James MacLeod - Managing Director, Tobin Brothers Funerals
Tuesday, June 13, 2017


As Managing Director of Tobin Brothers I’d like to make the following comments on a recently released paper “It’s your funeral, an investigation of death care in the Funeral Industry in Australia” written by Professor Sandra van der Laan (University of Sydney Business School) and Associate Professor Lee Moerman (University of Wollongong). 

Transparency in the funeral industry in Australia

The findings of this paper confirm my own personal belief that by and large there still continues to be a lack of transparency in the funeral industry across Australia. As the report states, people are vulnerable and need to make informed decisions.

We agree that all funeral companies should be required to display pricing for all goods and services that they offer. Tobin Brothers Funerals displays all of its pricing (and has done so for seven years) on our website, in our Goods and Services booklet, and on our MemoryMaker App which can be downloaded via the App Store or Googleplay.

At Tobin Brothers we make no apologies for being the most transparent funeral company in Australia, we want our client families to make informed decisions when planning a funeral.

Regulatory Environment

At Tobin Brothers we strongly believe greater regulations are required in the funeral industry in the State of Victoria.

In and around :

  • Staff training
  • Regulated mortuaries
  • Regulated refrigeration
  • Regulated and licensed facilities
  • Regulated and licensed staff members to care for loved ones
  • Regulated vehicles for deceased loved ones to be transported in 

Whilst the Australian Funeral Directors Association (AFDA) requires members to adhere to many of these requirements they do not go far enough. Many funeral companies in Victoria are not members of the AFDA. The standard of many funeral companies facilities across the state of Victoria are not at all satisfactory. Many in the funeral industry in the state of Victoria are calling for deregulation of the cemeteries and crematorium act of 2003 and the cemeteries and crematoriums regulations of 2015.

At Tobin Brothers we are calling for greater regulations right across the funeral industry in Victoria. At Tobin Brothers Funerals we believe in transparency with our client families so they know where their loved one will be cared for and whom will care for them. We invite you to watch our series 'A Day in the Life Of...' on youtube and on our website to gain further insight into Tobin Brothers.

Coffins and caskets mark ups

The paper suggested coffins and caskets could be marked up by 1000%. Tobin Brothers Funerals has not increased its coffin or casket prices for seven consecutive years. The vast majority of the funeral industry have increased coffin and casket prices by approximately 20% in that time. The cost of an entry level coffin at Tobin Brothers is $908. The cost of the exact same coffin varies from funeral company to funeral company, some will charge $1200, $1500, $1600 and even $2100 for the same coffin. All coffins and caskets at Tobin Brothers Funerals are available to view and costs on our website and on our MemoryMaker App.

Funeral Insurance

The paper also points out and states that the advertising of funeral insurance reinforces the idea that funerals are expensive and this impression provides opportunities to exploit vulnerable consumers. To receive the best guide on paying for a funeral the paper has a number of recommendations in and around greater transparency, with greater regulations around funeral insurance, and we would welcome further discussions.

To obtain the facts around what is the best preplanning funeral product visit

The report spends much time on price being the only deciding factor when engaging a funeral director for a loved one’s funeral. We agree price should be a consideration but it should not be the only consideration because many in the funeral industry will do a funeral at a low price because they need the practice. You will often here us say at Tobin Brothers that funerals are too important just to leave to anyone. For me this report confirms that. I encourage all members of the community to do their due diligence. 

If transparency is non existant on the firms website you can be sure that it won’t be at the touch points throughout your loved ones funeral experience.


James MacLeod

Managing Director, Tobin Brothers Funerals

Leave a comment
Please enter the numbers and letters you see in the image. Note that the case of the letters entered matters.


Please wait

Previous Posts

Celebrating the Life of Father Gerard Dowling OAM DE

Fr Gerard Dowling OAM DE  (1932-2023) Fr Gerard was a close friend of Tobin Brothers, a tremendous writer, radio host, qualified counsellor and a Catholic Priest to the Archdiocese for 65 yea...

Father Gerard Dowling OAM DE celebrates 50 years on radio!

On Sunday 3rd September 2023, Fr Gerard Dowling OAM DE celebrated a wonderful milestone of 50 years on Sunday evenings on the radio.   It was in 1973 that Fr Gerard first hosted his first ra...

Lessons from Fr Bob Maguire

In 1960, Rev Fr Robert Maguire AM PE RFD affectionately known to all as Fr Bob was ordained. Over the last 60-plus years, so many of our team members at Tobin Brothers have had the privilege to wor...

Celebrating Father Gerard Dowling

  Today we would like to pay tribute to Fr Gerard Dowling OAM DE. In recent weeks he celebrated his 90th birthday and also the 49th anniversary of him being on air with the Family Counsellor...

The day Queen Elizabeth II came to Frankston

It was Friday 7th March 1986 and I was 15 years old, attending Ballam Park Technical School in Frankston.  One of the largest schools in the area, Ballam Park had been selected for Que...

Christmas Message 2021

  In 2020, they said it was a year that we will remember, we can add 2021 to that also. Back-to-back unforgettable years. The last two years have challenged us all in so many varied ways, an...

Escape from Neil’s Wheel: Good Friday Appeal Fundraiser

  Victoria’s Good Friday Appeal, is one of the most important annual events in the state, raising funds to enable The Royal Children’s hospital in Melbourne to provide world class care for ...

Christmas Message 2020

In our lifetimes there has never been a more important time to gather. As 2020 commenced, after our country was crippled with bushfires and so many tragically lost their homes and some their loved...

Beating COVID19 is a community effort

It was On 23rd March 2020 that Tobin Brothers Funerals cared for its first COVID19 death. Since that time, we have cared for over 100 clients who have died from this hideous virus. Over my 30 plus ...

Get the Test Done

  In March 2020 I turned 50, it was a very quiet celebration as we had just commenced going into COVID19 lockdown. A few weeks after I turned 50 a parcel arrived for me in the post, a prese...